Wish Review: CLAMP's Shortest Romance — an Angel Falls to Earth and a Doctor Cannot Ignore Her

An angel is stuck in a tree in Tokyo. A doctor walking by cannot leave her there. She offers him any wish as payment for the rescue. He cannot think of one.

I'm Yu. Wish is four volumes. It ends in the most honest way CLAMP could have chosen.

Quick Take

• CLAMP's Wish (ウィッシュ) ran in Asuka Fantasy DX — complete in 4 tankōbon volumes.
• Dark Horse Comics published the English edition; complete and available.
• Rated T (Teen) — angel and demon mythology; bittersweet romance; gentle rather than heavy.

Story Overview

Kohaku is a cherub — small, cheerful, and carrying an enormous amount of goodwill. She gets stuck in a tree outside a hospital. A doctor named Shuichiro Kudo rescues her.

Kohaku offers him any wish as repayment. Shuichiro cannot think of one. He has everything he needs and does not want anything in particular. He asks her to stay until he thinks of a wish.

What follows is a cohabitation romance between a small angel and a quiet human doctor, complicated by the attention her presence draws from heaven and hell. Kohaku's supervisor Hisui and a pair of demons become involved for different reasons. At the center of it: Kohaku's developing feelings for Shuichiro, and a man who has spent his entire life without a single desire.

The series ran contemporaneously with CLAMP's X/1999, which was doing the opposite of everything Wish does — maximum darkness, maximum scale, maximum violence. Wish is four volumes of deliberate gentleness.

Characters

Kohaku — An angel whose cheerfulness is genuine and whose developing feelings for Shuichiro are drawn with real care. CLAMP gives her specific emotional responses rather than treating her as a placeholder for angelic innocence.

Shuichiro Kudo — His inability to wish for anything is the series' premise and its emotional core. His quiet kindness and his particular lack of desire are related. The series' whole interest is in what eventually breaks through that.

Hisui — Kohaku's supervisor in heaven, whose own complicated feelings add dimension to the divine-and-mortal premise.

What I Love About It

Shuichiro has no wish. The series spends four volumes with a premise where the expected genre mechanics — angel grants wish, story ends — are suspended indefinitely by a man who simply does not want anything.

What his eventual wish turns out to be is what makes everything before it retroactively complete.

CLAMP understood what they were doing. The gentleness is not accidental. This is a series about the kind of desire that cannot be named until the right person gives it a name.

Memorable Scene ⚠️ Spoiler Warning

Shuichiro's wish, when he finally articulates it, is the series' most precise emotional moment. Its specific nature makes everything that preceded it retroactively meaningful. It is the answer to a question that was always there.

Pros & Cons

Pros:

• CLAMP's gentlest work — a tonal rarity in their catalog.
• Complete in 4 volumes; the emotional scope is perfectly matched to the length.
• Kohaku's character design and emotional expressiveness are among CLAMP's best.
• Accessible to CLAMP newcomers and to readers who prefer warmth over drama.

Cons:

• The angel-and-demon mythology is light rather than developed — supporting cast exists for narrative function rather than depth.
• Bittersweet ending may surprise readers expecting pure sweetness.
• Short format limits secondary character space.

Is Wish Worth Reading?

Yes — for readers who want CLAMP's warmth without X/1999's tragedy or Chobits' maturity. Four volumes is a minimal commitment for what it offers. The ending earns its gentleness.

Who Is This Manga For?

• Readers who want a short, complete CLAMP romance.
• Anyone who enjoys angel-and-human stories with genuine warmth rather than dark undertones.
• CLAMP fans who want to experience the full range of the group's work.
• Readers looking for a contained fantasy romance that resolves completely.

Official English Translation Status

Dark Horse Comics published the English edition. Original TOKYOPOP volumes also available secondhand.

Where to Buy

Dark Horse Comics' complete English edition.

Browse Wish on Amazon →

---

This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.