A Devil and Her Love Song Review: A Girl Who Says Exactly What She Thinks Enters a School That Cannot Handle Her

Quick Take

• The shoujo manga that centers on a protagonist whose specific problem is saying true things that people don't want to hear — and the specific cost that honesty carries in social environments designed around pleasant fictions
• Maria Kawai is one of the most unusual shoujo protagonists: difficult, abrasive, genuinely kind in ways her social manner obscures
• 13 volumes complete in English; for readers who want romance with genuine social complexity

Who Is This Manga For?

• Readers who want shoujo romance that takes social dynamics seriously rather than simplifying them
• Anyone who responds to female protagonists who are difficult rather than conventionally likable
• Fans of romance that develops through genuine character understanding rather than easy attraction
• Readers who appreciate music as a genuine element of manga story rather than backdrop

Content Warnings & Age Rating

Age Rating: T (Teen) Content Warnings: Social exclusion and bullying are ongoing themes (the protagonist navigates class hostility throughout); emotional difficulty; the religious academy backstory involves abuse of authority; Maria's honesty causes genuine harm in places

More emotionally complex than the genre average. The social dynamics are serious.

Yu's Rating

Category	Score
Story Depth	★★★★☆
Art Style	★★★★☆
Character Development	★★★★★
Accessibility for Non-Japanese Readers	★★★★☆
Reread Value	★★★★☆

Story Overview

Maria Kawai was expelled from a prestigious private religious academy — the exact reason is gradually revealed. She transfers to a public high school where she immediately becomes a target for her class due to her inability (or refusal) to soften what she says.

She perceives what's actually happening in social situations with uncomfortable clarity — who is lying to who, what the pleasant social fictions are concealing, what motivates cruelty that presents as niceness. She says it. No one is prepared for this.

Two boys in her class respond differently: Yusuke Kanda, who manages the class dynamics, feels challenged and intrigued by her honesty. Shin Meguro, whose own social situation is complicated, is drawn to her by recognition.

The series follows Maria's navigation of high school social life and the music that becomes her medium for expressing what words can't fully contain.

Characters

Maria Kawai — Her specific difficulty — not cruelty, not malice, but an inability to perform the pleasantries that hold social situations together — is drawn with genuine sympathy. She is kind in the sense that matters most: she sees people truly and that matters to them.

Shin Meguro — His parallel difficulty (he also cannot be what people expect) and his specific recognition of Maria creates the romance's most resonant foundation. His character development runs alongside hers.

Yusuke Kanda — His role as class social manager and his complicated attraction to Maria generate the series' central romantic triangle, which is handled with more nuance than typical genre triangles.

Art Style

Tomori's art is clean and expressive — the character expressions, particularly Maria's specific look of clarity while everyone around her is distressed, are precisely drawn. The choir/music sequences are rendered with care for the physical experience of singing.

Cultural Context

A Devil and Her Love Song ran in Bessatsu Margaret and takes its religious school setting seriously — the specific ethical framework of the Catholic school Maria came from, and how it shaped her, is developed as character background rather than simply atmosphere. The music element (choir) is specific to that background and becomes her most authentic form of expression.

What I Love About It

The spin on kindness. Maria has what she calls a "lovely spin" — the ability to reframe what she perceives into something that protects the other person. She chooses when to apply it. Watching her learn that genuine honesty and protective kindness are not opposites — that seeing someone truly is itself a form of care — is the series' most careful character work.

What English-Speaking Fans Say

Western readers describe A Devil and Her Love Song as the shoujo romance they remember most specifically — not the most light or enjoyable, but the most distinctive in its protagonist. Maria's inability to perform social niceness resonates with readers who have experienced similar situations, and her gradual acceptance by the people who choose to understand her is among the genre's more genuinely moving arcs.

Memorable Scene ⚠️ Spoiler Warning

The full revelation of what happened at the religious academy — what Maria did, what was done to her, and the specific injustice at the center of her expulsion — reframes her initial characterization completely and is the series' most emotionally serious moment.

Similar Manga

• Say I Love You — Social outsider finding connection, similar warmth
• Kimi ni Todoke — Social difficulty from different angle, similar character warmth
• We Were There — Emotionally demanding romance in similar Bessatsu Margaret register
• Strobe Edge — First love with genuine emotional complexity

Reading Order / Where to Start

Volume 1 — Maria's introduction and immediate class conflict establish her character completely.

Official English Translation Status

Viz Media published the complete 13-volume run in their Shojo Beat imprint. All volumes available.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Maria Kawai is one of shoujo's most unusual and memorable protagonists
• The character development is thorough and earned across 13 volumes
• The music element adds genuine depth
• Complete with a satisfying resolution

Cons

• The social exclusion dynamics can be painful to read
• Maria's abrasiveness in the early volumes requires patience
• The romantic triangle takes longer to resolve than some readers prefer

Format Comparison

Format	Notes
Individual Volumes	Viz Media Shojo Beat; standard
Digital	Available

Where to Buy

Get A Devil and Her Love Song Vol. 1 on Amazon →

---

This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.